hannasus: (Default)
And premiere week continues apace...

Cane is just... boring as all get out. It's soapy and predictable and cliched and not one of the characters cracked a smile the entire episode. Basically it's Falcon Crest with Cubans, which turns out to be no more interesting than Falcon Crest with white people was. Fail.

Dirty Sexy Money, on the other hand, is a total win. Dark and amusing and quirky and fascinating. Like some kind delicious middle ground between Arrested Development and The Royal Tenenbaums, with a dash of Agatha Christie-style murder mystery thrown in for good measure. The genius of this pilot is that despite the huge cast, each of the Darling siblings are so well-characterized and brilliantly introduced that you never have trouble keeping them straight. I'll definitely be studying this script for technique when I start working on my spec pilot.

Reaper, which I saw at Comic-con and realize now I never posted about, is also tons of fun, and has a cherished place in my Season Pass list until the CW cancels it because no one watches the CW.

The second episode of K-Ville was slightly better than the pilot so I'm hanging with it for a little longer to see how it goes. Still pretty standard fare, and they need to come up with an A story other than exposing corporate corruption in the rebuilding efforts, but the cinematography is pretty.

Private Practice seemed a little improved from the spring pilot. No talking elevators and no idiotic "I'm going to kiss you with tongue" monologues definitely makes for a less embarrassing hour of television. I'm not at all impressed with Audra McDonald as Merrin Dungey's replacement, but I'm kinda sorta besotted with Cooper and Violet so it evens out. And Kate Walsh's dancing at the beginning of the ep was so hilariously bad that I'm going to keep watching just to see if she does it every week.

So, for those who are keeping track, here's my official tally of the season so far--

Definitely worth watching:

Pushing Daisies
Chuck
Reaper
Life
Dirty Sexy Money

Definitely NOT worth watching:

Cane
The Big Bang Theory

Hovering somewhere in between:

Bionic Woman
Journeyman
K-Ville
Gossip Girl
Private Practice

Frankly, it's turning out to be a pretty impressive slate this season. The big question is how many of my must-watch shows will make it past Christmas.
hannasus: (Default)
It's premiere week! Hooray! Bring on the new TV!

Last week I watched K-Ville and Gossip Girl, neither of which were particularly impressive. Gossip Girl felt like a retread of the O.C. only with less interesting characters. And Kristen Bell's narration felt awkward and distracting. It's fine for what it is I guess, but what it is just doesn't interest me much.

In her blog, television writer Jill Golick enthusiastically deconstructed the K-Ville pilot, praising it for its structural elegance. What's interesting to me is how she managed to completely overlook the fact that it's just not very good. Sure, the structure's technically adept, but that doesn't necessarily translate to compelling writing.

Which is a shame, because I think it's great to have a prime-time drama focusing on the situation in New Orleans, and even better that it's actually shot on location, a la Friday Night Lights. And it is a beautifully photographed show that uses the setting to lovely effect. Unfortunately, it's also about as subtle as an anvil to the head.

K-Ville is a show that's just plain trying too hard. Instead of letting the shadow of Katrina delicately inform the story and characters, it constantly beats you over the head with it like an ABC Afterschool Special. The story is trite and completely predictable--everything that happens is exactly what you'd expect to happen in a mediocre cop drama. Worst of all, there's no actual complexity to the characters, no matter how hard they work at furrowing their brows somberly, and consequently most of the scenes fall flat.

Cole Hauser does all right with what he's got to work with, but Anthony Anderson just doesn't have the range to carry his half of the dramatic weight. And none of the actors are from anywhere near Louisiana, which shows painfully in the way they struggle with their accents. This, my friends, is no Friday Night Lights.

Thanks to Amazon Unbox I also got an early glimpse of Bionic Woman, Journeyman, Life, and The Big Bang Theory. And of those four the one I was least expecting to enjoy--Life--was the one I enjoyed the most. On its face it's pretty much a standard cop drama, but Damian Lewis is fantastic and edgy and delightfully fun as the lead. Journeyman and Bionic Woman were both okay, but I'm going to have to watch a few more episodes before I decide if it's worth sticking with them. The Big Bang Theory may be okay once it finds its feet, but in the pilot the characters are painted far too broadly and while I did actually laugh once or twice, some of the jokes were just plain offensive to me as a geek. Note to the writers: watching Battlestar Galactica is not, in and of itself, a punchline.

Expand Cut Tags

No cut tags

Profile

hannasus: (Default)
hannasus

Syndicate

RSS Atom

Most Popular Tags

Style Credit

Page generated Sep. 25th, 2017 05:59 am
Powered by Dreamwidth Studios
October 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 23 24 25 26 27 28 29 30 31 2010